8 Most Realistic Electric Fireplaces of 2020

Last update: Nov 26, 2020

When choosing a new electric fireplace, you have to think about how realistic is the fire. We all know the flame isn’t real, but still, we want to look at the soft glow that resembles an actual fire.

If you set up an electric fireplace to create an ambient feel for your living room, this factor will be even more potent.

So, what should we do to get the most realistic electric fireplaces?

Here are the most realistic electric fireplaces you can buy in 2020:

  • Best for Bedroom (Mantel Electric Fireplaces): Ameriwood Home Chicago Electric Fireplace
  • Best for Living Room (Mantel Electric Fireplaces): Comfort Smart Killian Electric Fireplace
  • Best for All-Year-Round Heating (Electric Fireplace Inserts): Touchstone 80014
  • Best for Study Room (Electric Fireplace Inserts): PuraFlame 26 Inches Western Electric Fireplace
  • Best for Bedroom (Wall-Mounted Electric Fireplaces): PuraFlame Alice 60 Inches Recessed Electric Fireplace
  • Quiet (Wall-Mounted Electric Fireplaces): XtremepowerUS Allure Linear Wall Mount Smokeless Electric
  • Best for Large Room (Freestanding Electric Fireplaces): TURBRO Suburbs TS20
  • Best for Small Room (Freestanding Electric Fireplaces): GMHome Free Standing Electric Fireplace
8 Most Realistic Electric Fireplaces
Best for Bedroom
Ameriwood Home Chicago Electric Fireplace
  • Mantel Electric Fireplaces
Best for Living Room
Comfort Smart Killian Electric Fireplace
  • Mantel Electric Fireplaces
Best for All-Year-Round Heating
Touchstone 80014
  • Electric Fireplace Inserts
Best for Study Room
PuraFlame 26 Inches Western Electric Fireplace
  • Electric Fireplace Inserts
Best for Bedroom
PuraFlame Alice 60 Inches Recessed Electric Fireplace
  • Wall-Mounted Electric Fireplaces
Quiet
XtremepowerUS Allure Linear Wall Mount Smokeless Electric
  • Wall-Mounted Electric Fireplaces
Best for Large Room
TURBRO Suburbs TS20
  • Freestanding Electric Fireplaces
Best for Small Room
GMHome Free Standing Electric Fireplace
  • Freestanding Electric Fireplaces

Best for Bedroom (Mantel Electric Fireplaces): Ameriwood Home Chicago Electric Fireplace

Ameriwood Home Chicago Electric Fireplace
Ameriwood Home Chicago Electric Fireplace
9Outstanding
Pros
  • Multifunctional – a TV stand, a heater, and a fireplace light
  • Heat up quick - 4600 BTUs & 400 sq. ft. of heating coverage
Cons
  • No remote control compatibility

The Ameriwood Home Chicago Electric Fireplace is very quiet and able to heat a master bedroom pretty fast. We love the fact that fireplace lights can be operated independently. You can get it from 60 degrees to 70 in about 15-25 minutes.

The biggest selling point is there’s just a minimal increase in our electric bill.

Its brilliant design allows for accommodating a max load of 70 pounds, like a 50” flat panel TV or anything you like. There are some added shelves for extra storage as well.

Note that this is a manual switch on and off unit and no remote is included, which is a bit inconvenient.

Ameriwood Home Chicago Electric Fireplace Specifications

Dimension

31.77”H x 47.24”W x 15.87”D

Wattage

1400 watts

BTUs

4600 BTUs

Heating Area

400 sq. ft.

Highlight Features

Work as a TV stand, a heater, and a fireplace light; 4600 BTUs & 400 sq. ft. of heating coverage

Verdict

For folks who want a great value for their bedroom, this Ameriwood Home Chicago Electric Fireplace is a fantastic buy.

Best for Living Room (Mantel Electric Fireplaces): Comfort Smart Killian Electric Fireplace

Comfort Smart Killian Electric Fireplace
Comfort Smart Killian Electric Fireplace
9Outstanding
Pros
  • Appealing and make a good focal point – feature interesting barndoor-inspired cabinets, appealing Ashland Pine finish, and rustic cottage design
  • Energy-efficient – save lots of money on the electricity bills
  • Easy to put together
Cons
  • Mess up instructions
  • The pre-drilled holes could be better

With the interesting barndoor-inspired cabinets, appealing Ashland Pine finish, and rustic cottage design, the Comfort Smart Killian Electric Fireplace will definitely make you the envy of your friends when having this in your living room.

It should fit a 55-inch TV or anything weighing under 45 pounds.

Aside from the realistic fireplace lights, it is equipped with a heater with 400-square-foot coverage.

By using it for supplemental heat in the room you are in and turning down your central thermostat, you’ll save a bunch on your utility bill.

Comfort Smart Killian Electric Fireplace Specifications

Dimension

15.5 x 47.5 x 27 inches

BTUs

4600 BTUs

Heating Area

400 Sq. Ft.

Highlight Features

interesting barndoor-inspired cabinets, appealing Ashland Pine finish, and rustic cottage design

Verdict

If you are looking for a TV stand with a heating source in it to help take the chill out of the air in the living room, pick this!

Best for All-Year-Round Heating (Electric Fireplace Inserts): Touchstone 80014

Touchstone 80014
Touchstone 80014
9Outstanding
Pros
  • Controllable and customizable – multiple brightness settings & five realistic flame modes
  • Convenient to use – compatible with remote control
  • Create a more authentic feel – include a crystal glass and faux fire logs
  • Able to provide heat – two heat settings
Cons
  • The heater fan is loud
  • Directions are pretty poor
  • The blower could be a bit stronger

The Touchstone 80014 is the most beautiful electric fireplace insert that we’ve found.

It provides multiple brightness settings ranging from full blazing light to a dull ember glow for different moods and ambience wanted. There additionally are five realistic flame settings to choose from, all can be adjusted through remote control.

We do appreciate the thoughtfulness of Touchstone when they even add some faux fire logs for a more authentic feel.

With such beautiful, delicate design, you can use it all-year-round.

But that’s not all about this model, you will also get two heat settings for extra warmth during the cold seasons with adjustable heat levels.

Touchstone 80014 Specifications

Dimension

36 x 5.5 x 21.4 inches

Wattage

1500/750 Watt

BTUs

5118 BTUs

Heating Area

400 square feet.

Highlight Features

multiple brightness settings & five realistic flame modes; compatible with remote control; include a crystal glass and faux fire logs

Verdict

For anyone who is looking for a fireplace wall insert that can be used all-year-round, we highly recommend Touchstone 80014.

Best for Study Room (Electric Fireplace Inserts): PuraFlame 26 Inches Western Electric Fireplace

PuraFlame 26 Inches Western Electric Fireplace
PuraFlame 26 Inches Western Electric Fireplace
9.4Outstanding
Pros
  • Ultra-quite - hardly hear the blower on either setting
  • Full of control - two volumes of the crackling sounds and two settings for flames
  • User-friendly - remote control compatibility
Cons
  • The remote control could work better

Compared to other electric fireplace inserts we’ve tried, this is the quietest model that we hardly hear the blower on either setting.

In those silent spaces, you probably hear a low, soft blowing noise like a ceiling fan on medium but that’s not distracting. That’s why we suggest it for study rooms.

Regardless, it looks quite realistic behind the fireplace screen and glass. There are two volumes of the crackling sounds and two settings for flames to choose from. You’ve also got the heat option for those cold, chilly days.

A big plus is it also includes a remote control for extra convenience.

PuraFlame 26 Inches Western Electric Fireplace Specifications

Dimension

Width: 27.95" x Height: 24.61" x Depth: 8.78".

Wattage

750/1500W

BTUs

5118 BTUs

Heating Area

400 sq. ft.

Highlight Features

Quiet operation; two volumes of the crackling sounds and two settings for flames; remote control compatibility

Verdict

If you’ve been finding the perfect electric fireplace insert for study room use, the PuraFlame 26 Inches Western Electric Fireplace is a shining contender.

Best for Bedroom (Wall-Mounted Electric Fireplaces): PuraFlame Alice 60 Inches Recessed Electric Fireplace

PuraFlame Alice 60 Inches Recessed Electric Fireplace
PuraFlame Alice 60 Inches Recessed Electric Fireplace
8.8Great
Pros
  • Create a realistic and modern look – provide several flame color choices and different rock color options
  • Able to customize – the heater than the fireplace can be controlled separately
  • Run quietly
Cons
  • The remote control is a bit finicky to use
  • The “flicker speed” isn’t adjustable

This wall-mounted electric fireplace will make a huge difference in your bedroom. The rocks can be lit in many different color options and the flames have several color choices as well. They are all impressively realistic and look modern.

It works with or without the hot air feature if you want warmth or just ambiance. With the heater on, this electric fireplace puts out a good deal of heat.

About the noise, except for the audible “beep” when changing effect settings, it is very quiet that you can barely hear the fan.

We also like the touch screen and the ease of using it. For the price, this is a great piece.

PuraFlame Alice 60 Inches Recessed Electric Fireplace Specifications

Dimension

60 1/4” Width x 20 1/4” Height x 6 1/6” Depth,

Wattage

high 1500W and low 750W

BTUs

5120 BTUs.

Heating Area

400 to 500 square feet

Highlight Features

provide several flame color choices and different rock color options; Run quietly

Verdict

If you’re in need of something that looks good and operates quietly for bedrooms, this is exactly what you’re after.

Quiet (Wall-Mounted Electric Fireplaces): XtremepowerUS Allure Linear Wall Mount Smokeless Electric

XtremepowerUS Allure Linear Wall Mount Smokeless Electric
XtremepowerUS Allure Linear Wall Mount Smokeless Electric
8.8Great
Pros
  • Heat up fast with huge coverage – take around 5-15 minutes to warm a 400-square-foot space
  • Easy to install – simple construction & readable instructions
  • Whisper quiet while operating
Cons
  • Wish the flames were more realistic

If you need a quieter option, try the XtremepowerUS Allure Linear Wall Mount Smokeless Electric.

While the heater is able to warm a 400-square-foot space within 5-15 minutes, we hardly hear its operating blower. So for those who are extremely sensitive to noise, this is worth a look.

It’s also easy to install. The instructions are simple and only take around 30 minutes to finish.

We really like the visual aspect of it. There are three flame color settings to choose from and the interesting thing is you can either control them one-by-one or combine many of them together as wanted.

XtremepowerUS Allure Linear Wall Mount Smokeless Electric Specifications

Dimension

50 x 6 x 18.5 inches

Wattage

750/1500W

Heating Area

400 square feet

Highlight Features

a 400-square-foot coverage; quick heating; readable instructions

Verdict

We love that the XtremepowerUS Allure Linear Wall Mount Smokeless Electric is quieter than most of other similar counterparts out there, making it the most suited for people who hate noise.

Best for Large Room (Freestanding Electric Fireplaces): TURBRO Suburbs TS20

TURBRO Suburbs TS20
TURBRO Suburbs TS20
8.6Great
Pros
  • Provide fake flames look very similar to a gas stove - vintage door design with 3-sided panoramic viewing glass
  • Able to range to as low as 68F – feature a thermostat
Cons
  • The legs are plastic

The TURBRO Suburbs TS20 is super-cute.

A thumb-up for its vintage door design with 3-sided panoramic viewing glass, which makes the fake flames look very similar to a gas stove, creating a very cozy atmosphere.

What's very unique about this fireplace is that it has a thermostat and it can range to as low as 68F.

Giving 4777 BTUs with decently huge heating coverage, no doubt when this unit can heat up a room very fast. It also helps add supplement heat to the house significantly.

TURBRO Suburbs TS20 Specifications

Dimension

20H x 17W x 10D

Wattage

1,400W

BTUs

4,777BTU

Heating Area

1,000 sq.ft.

Highlight Features

vintage door design with 3-sided panoramic viewing glass; feature a thermostat

Verdict

The TURBRO Suburbs TS20 is by far one of the most realistic electric fireplaces for large rooms on the market and most of all, it’s set at a price that can’t be cheaper.

Best for Small Room (Freestanding Electric Fireplaces): GMHome Free Standing Electric Fireplace

GMHome Free Standing Electric Fireplace
GMHome Free Standing Electric Fireplace
8.6Great
Pros
  • Give a cute look - white design with glass viewing window
  • Able to provide real supplemental heat – two heat settings
  • Easy to assemble - come completely assembled except for the legs
Cons
  • No thermostat
  • Wish the top and legs were metal

The GMHome Free Standing is a perfect decoration as well as a functional mini heater for small rooms.

Its beautiful white design with a glass viewing window paints a very cozy picture in the space, especially during cold seasons. We are very pleased that it has 2 heat settings for real supplemental heat.

A big bonus is it comes completely assembled except for the legs which were easy to attach. All you need to do is just screwing on legs and plugging in.

Although it’s made of plastic, this freestanding electric fireplace is still durable enough to withstand something on its top like a vase or picture frame.

GMHome Free Standing Electric Fireplace Specifications

Dimension

15""W x 10.6""D x 22""H

Wattage

750/1500W

Heating Area

400 sq ft.

Highlight Features

white design with glass viewing window; two heat settings; come completely assembled

Verdict

This cute, cozy freestanding electric fireplace is a great choice for small rooms. It can heat up a 400-square-foot room really fast and the flames are attractive.

How To Choose The Most Realistic Electric Fireplace?

Flame technology

Technology has benefited us with electric fireplaces, and technological advancement has granted us with fireplaces that look as real as we can imagine. And a technology you can count on for a realistic fireplace is 3D Flame Effect, created by ClassicFlame.

It not only generates a realistic look for the fireplace, but it also allows you to customize the flames in accordance with your preference.

For instance, you can choose a color that fits your mood the most, a campfire or sapphire flames, etc.

Flame accents

Like we try to resemble a foreign accent to practice a language, an electric flame needs a realistic accent to resemble the real one.

Therefore, when choosing an electric fireplace, you should also consider the warmth from the flame as well as smaller details like the ember bed or the glowing log. Despite being small, when coming together, they will generate a perfect feel of the fireplace.

Settings

Last but not least, you need settings that match your electric flame so that it could look the best possible.

Despite not having a real flame, you can set up a real fireplace to house the electric flame. This will make the whole thing feel closer than ever to real life.

Which Brands Make The Most Realistic Electric Fireplace?

Ameriwood

This is a leading brand in terms of wood furniture.

With Ameriwood, you can choose a TV stand that features a small fireplace underneath. That will add a cozy feel to your living room. Otherwise, you can opt for a standalone electric fireplace, which is larger and more suitable to cover a wall.

Ameriwood offers electric fireplaces in many styles and designs so you can freely pick the one that fits your house the most.

Touchstone

Touchstone comes up with a wide selection of electric fireplace with great diversity regarding looks and designs for you to choose from. Besides, it also sells remote control so that you can easily monitor the virtual flame from a distance.

PuraFlame

Puraflame offers electric fireplaces across different types like in-wall recessed, wall-mounted, and electric stove. Its product portfolio includes fireplaces of varying sizes that can go up to 68 inches if your house is large.

XtremepowerUS

This brand offers wall-mounted fireplaces as well as wood stands that house electric fireplaces. So, depending on your preference and living arrangement, you can choose a design that best fits the place. You can also get a remote control for monitoring the flames.

TURBO

Rather than wall-mounted electric fireplaces, the best selling and featured product of TURBO is the freestanding electric fireplace. If you want an electric fireplace that looks both compact, simple, and elegant, TURBO is your go-to brand.

FAQs

Do electric fireplace flames look real?

It depends on the model you choose. The one featuring the latest flame technology and accents will give look real the most.

Can you leave the electric fireplace overnight?

Yes, you can. This is not a real fireplace, it will not emit CO when “burning,” so you can leave it on overnight if you want.

Do the electric fireplaces really heat a room?

Testing shows that an electric fireplace can raise the room temperature by 13.5 degrees F within 4 hours. But don’t worry, it still feels cool to the touch.

How much electricity does an electric fireplace use?

An electric fireplace uses just 1,500 W of electricity, equivalent to 3 cents or less per hour.

Are electric fireplaces quiet?

There are two types of electric fireplaces on the market – one with no sound effects and another has. If you want yours to be quiet, just choose the first type.

Do electric fireplaces damage TV?

No, they don’t.

There are TV stand housing an electric fireplace, but it won’t do harm to the TV because the heat it generates emits from beneath the “fire.”

Conclusion

Electric fireplaces are a great way to decorate your room and make it warmer, generating an ambient atmosphere for the room.

To have to best experience with a virtual fireplace, you need to think of the flame technology, accent, and the entire settings when choosing an electric fireplace. Each detail can be small, but when cooperated together, they will help create the perfect fireplace for your home.


Related Articles