If your old mattress is not supportive anymore, instead of having a new mattress, you can consider adding a mattress topper.
Here are the most comfortable mattress toppers you can buy in 2024:
- Best Overall (Memory Foam): Sleep Innovations 4-inch Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam
- Best for Pressure Relief (Memory Foam): LUCID 2 Inch 5 Zone Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Good Looking (Memory Foam): Milemont Mattress Topper
- Best Plush Feeling (Down Alternative): SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper
- Best for Warm Weather (Down Alternative): LUCID Ultra Plush 3 Inch Down Alternative Fiber
- Best for Pain Relief (Latex): Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper
- Best Luxury (Latex): Ultimate Dreams Talalay Latex
| 7 Most Comfortable Mattress Toppers | ||
|---|---|---|
Best Overall | Sleep Innovations 4-inch Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam
| |
Best for Pressure Relief | LUCID 2 Inch 5 Zone Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
| |
Good Looking | Milemont Mattress Topper
| |
Best Plush Feeling | SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper
| |
Best for Warm Weather | LUCID Ultra Plush 3 Inch Down Alternative Fiber
| |
Best for Pain Relief | Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper
| |
Best Luxury | Ultimate Dreams Talalay Latex
| |
Memory foam
Memory foam is a great choice for upper back pain sufferers. It contours to your body, so it evenly supports every part of your body, reducing pressure points up to 80%. Moreover, memory foam absorbs movement, which means if you share your bed with someone else, you don’t need to worry about what you are doing in your half disturbing your partner. Memory foam is a great choice for mattress topper, both comfortable and supportive.
Best Overall (Memory Foam): Sleep Innovations 4-inch Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam
2 layers & 4-inch thick
Cooling gel memory foam
Hypoallergenic
Removable & machine-washable cover
10-year limited warranty
- Unpleasant smell at first
Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam is the first mattress topper in my list. It is supportive and soft with 2 layers, one is 2-inch quilted fiberfill, the other is 2-inch cooling gel memory foam. The cover can be removable and machine-washable for easier cleaning. Moreover, the topper is made of materials that ensure hypoallergenic quality, ideal for those who are sensitive.
The 2-inch memory foam is cooling-gel infused so that it does not trap heat and stays cool all night. Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam evenly supports your body as it contours to your body perfectly, helping you get rid of back and neck pains, especially upper back pain.
Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam comes in many sizes. I highly recommend choosing this topper when you share bed with someone else since it absorbs movements and does not bounce at all. Moreover, you are assured of a 10-year warranty when buying this topper. However, it may smell unpleasantly in the first few days, after that the smell will be gone.
| Sleep Innovations 4-inch Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam Specifications | |
|---|---|
Size | Twin; Full; Queen; King; California King |
Weight | 16.91 pounds (Twin) |
Material | 2" of quilted fiber fill & 2" of cooling gel memory foam |
Cover | Yes |
Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam is supportive and comfortable with 2 layers.
Best for Pressure Relief (Memory Foam): LUCID 2 Inch 5 Zone Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
5 zones targeted to maximize comfort
Cooling gel infused & Ventilated for air circulation
Raised texture patterns to distribute weight
Affordable
Quite thin and squishy
LUCID Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper is an affordable choice. It is twice as thin as Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam. It consists of only 2-inch memory foam with raised texture patterns on its surface. It looks quite squishy and comes with no cover; however, I consider it has a very good quality for the price.
LUCID Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper features five different raised-pattern zones to alleviate pressure at common pressure points of the body, reducing tossing and turning during the night. The topper is cooling-gel infused and ventilated for air circulation, keeping you cool all night.
However, since the topper is so thin, you should use it with a thick mattress under it.
| LUCID 2 Inch 5 Zone Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper Specifications | |
|---|---|
Size | Twin; Twin XL; Full; Full XL; Queen; King; California King |
Weight | 5.5 pounds (Twin) |
Material | 2-inch memory foam |
Cover | sold separately |
LUCID Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper has raised patterns for optimal pressure relief.
Good Looking (Memory Foam): Milemont Mattress Topper
Great presentation
Cooling, cozy, and healthy sleep
CertiPUR-US Certified
Backed by 10-year warranty
- Does not have a cover
Milemont Mattress Topper is CertiPUR-US certified for hospitality-industrial grade quality. The standard ensures that the topper is toxic-chemical free and biodegradable, letting you enjoy a healthy and cozy sleep. However, it does not come with a cover.
Milemont Mattress Topper looks appealing with wave-like blue patterns. Despite being only 2-inch thick, the topper is extra soft and contours perfectly to your body. It is infused with cooling gel and has a breathable open-cell design to stay cool all night. You can buy this topper with 100% confidence as it is backed by a 10-year warranty.
If you want a thicker topper, you can choose the 3-inch option.
| Milemont Mattress Topper Specifications | |
|---|---|
Size | Twin; Full; Queen; King |
Weight | 7.39 pounds (Twin) |
Material | 2-inch cooling-gel infused memory foam |
Cover | No |
Milemont Mattress Topper is a good-looking topper, backed by a 10-year warranty.
Down alternative
Down alternative is softer than memory foam; however, because of that, it is not as supportive as memory foam is. If softness is your priority, down alternative mattress top is the choice for you. One advantage of down alternative over natural down is that it is usually hypoallergenic.
Best Plush Feeling (Down Alternative): SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper
Super thick
Breathable & Healthy
Soft & Comfortable
Durable & Machine washable
It gets warm
SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper is super thick, which provides you with the feeling “sleeping on a cloud”. It is stuffed 50% more than other toppers in the market, with incremental HTMicrofiber filling, for softness and quietness. More filling also means the topper will keep its shape longer. It is soft and comfortable yet still supportive thanks to more filling.
The cover is made of 100% 400TC cotton fabric that is breathable and durable. It is also machine-washable for easier maintenance. However, since it is extra thick, it does trap heat and gets warm.
| SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper Specifications | |
|---|---|
Size | Twin; Twin XL; Full; Queen; King; California King |
Weight | 6.93 pounds (Twin) |
Material | incremental HT Microfiber |
Cover | Cotton |
SOPAT Extra Thick Mattress Topper is durable and provides you with the best plush feeling.
Best for Warm Weather (Down Alternative): LUCID Ultra Plush 3 Inch Down Alternative Fiber
Odors, allergens, and quills resistant
Soft, breathable, comfortable, and durable
Thick SecureStrap elastic straps
Easy maintainance
- May go flat after a while
LUCID Ultra Plush is stuffed with down alternative polyester fiber, which makes the topper as soft as down topper yet hypoallergenic. It is resistant to odors, allergens, and quills as time goes by. The topper is 3-inch thick, providing you with a soft and comfortable feeling. The cotton cover is very durable that won’t tear and wear after years. It features elastic straps at four corners to fix the topper securely on your mattress.
LUCID Ultra Plush has a breathable shell for better air circulation. Baffle box stitching helps the filling distribute evenly, improving breathability. So the topper stays cool even in warm weather.
A drawback of LUCID Ultra Plush is that it may go flat after a while. To avoid this, you can regularly fluff it by hand or with a dryer - the purpose is to add more air trapped within the filling, keeping it airy and comfortable.
| LUCID Ultra Plush 3 Inch Down Alternative Fiber Specifications | |
|---|---|
Size | Twin; Full; Queen; King; California King; Full X-Large; Twin X-Large |
Weight | 6 pounds (Twin) |
Material | polyester fiber |
Cover | Cotton |
LUCID Ultra Plush is extra soft, hypoallergenic, durable, and stays cool during warm days.
Latex
Latex or rubber does not contour to your body as memory foam does. It just conforms to your general shape, however, well enough to support your body, relieving pressure. Latex also is very bouncy, which is the reason why couples don't like latex; however, it's pretty supportive if you sleep alone. So, if you want a firm mattress top, latex is for you.
Best for Pain Relief (Latex): Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper
100% Natural Latex
Amazing Pinpointed Support
Stays cool all night
Three thickness options & Three firmness options
Nothing to complain
Pure Green Natural Latex Topper is made of 100% natural latex, which means it is healthy and naturally cool. Moreover, it has ventilated holes on its surface, improving air circulation. The topper stays cool all night.
Pure Green Natural Latex Topper provides great comfort and support. It contours to the general shape of your body, providing support at the right spots. Natural latex is also very durable, it’ll last for at least a decade.
Pure Green Natural Latex Topper comes in three thickness options (1 inch, 2 inches, 3 inches) and firmness options (soft, medium, firm). It’s your choice to choose the most suitable one. Many complained that the topper was too firm, but maybe they had chosen the firmness option.
| Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper Specifications | |
|---|---|
Size | Twin; Twin XL, Full; Queen; King; Cal King |
Weight | 8.2 pounds (1-inch Twin) |
Material | Natural Latex |
Cover | No |
Pure Green Natural Latex Topper is 100% natural that is supportive, durable, and very cool.
Best Luxury (Latex): Ultimate Dreams Talalay Latex
Talalay latex
Naturally cooling effect
Luxurious feel & naturally resilient
Softness options: Soft, Medium, Firm
Durable, hypoallergenic, antibacterial
- Heavy and high price
Ultimate Dreams Queen Talalay Latex is the premium choice. First, Talalay latex is the crucial difference. Talalay latex is made of 100% natural latex; other than the process of making common latex, Talalay latex is flash-frozen before it's baked. This gives Talalay latex a more consistent cell structure, more premium quality.
Ultimate Dreams Queen Talalay Latex has a naturally cooling effect, so it stays cool all night. It is also naturally resilient and supportive, providing you with a luxurious and relaxing feeling. Its cover is made of bamboo fabric for more smoothness and coolness.
Moreover, the topper is durable, hypoallergenic, antibacterial, and resistant to dust mites, mold, and mildew, ensuring the best sleep for you. You can choose the topper softness level - soft, medium, and firm. However, of course, Ultimate Dreams Queen Talalay Latex is very expensive and very heavy.
| Ultimate Dreams Talalay Latex Specifications | |
|---|---|
Size | Twin; Twin XL; Full; Short Queen; Queen; King; California King |
Weight | 21.9 pounds (Twin) |
Material | Natural latex |
Cover | Natural bamboo fabric |
Ultimate Dreams Talalay Latex is naturally supportive, resilient, cool, hypoallergenic, and durable.
How To Choose The Most Comfortable Mattress Topper?
There are several choices of materials:
Memory Foam
Memory foam (often infused with a cooling gel) has a great advantage over other materials that it contours perfectly to your body. So, it supports every spot on your body, distributing the pressure evenly. Memory foam is a great choice for those who are suffering back pain. However, memory foam toppers tend to get warm, except for some well-designed ones.
Down Alternative
Down is favorited for its softness. Sleeping on a down mattress/topper is like sleeping on a cloud. However, down is natural materials that may contain some allergens. If you are allergic to natural down, down alternative, which is usually made of polyester fiber, is a good choice. It is as soft as natural down, moreover, durable, and hypoallergenic. Down alternative is a great choice for those who like an extra-plush topper.
Latex
Latex is a premium material. It is firmer than both memory foam and down alternative; however, it provides enough support. It contours to your general shape, helping alleviate pressure at common pressure points of the body. Natural latex is naturally cool and very responsive. A natural latex topper is a great choice for those like its firmness and responsiveness.
You’ll also need to consider these factors:
Cover
Some toppers come with a cover, some don’t. A removable and machine-washable cover makes it much easier to clean.
Firmness
Latex is the firmest among three common materials; down alternative is the softest; memory foam is in the middle. However, each topper has its own firmness quality. It depends on your preference to choose the topper’s firmness.
Coolness
This also depends on your preference. For example, I usually set my air conditioner at quite low and like to sleep on a mattress that keeps heat well. Other people may like the opposite. Some topper is designed for optimal air circulation so that it is better at staying cool all night.
Odors, allergens, and quills resistance
This is important since a topper is a place you sleep 8 hours a day. It should be hygienic and healthy.
Which Brands Make The Most Comfortable Mattress Topper?
Sleep Innovations
With 20 years of taking care of customers' sleep, Sleep Innovations is the brand that must be mentioned. It is the first band that introduced gel memory foam mattresses, which contours perfectly to your body yet stays cool all night. It quickly became the new standard for memory foam mattresses. They make all the foam for their bedding products in the US for the best quality control. So their mattresses are well-known for their great quality and backed by great customer service. If you are finding a gel memory foam mattress, Sleep Innovations is the brand to go.
Lucid Mattress
Lucid is another big brand of bedding products. They make from mattresses, toppers, to bed bases, headboards, pillows, and other bedroom accessories. In terms of mattresses, Lucid has a wide range of mattresses for different needs. They have mattresses for those who like firm feeling and for those who like plush feeling, who sleep on their back, stomach, and side, who like to sleep hot or cold. They have mattresses made of latex, memory foam, and down alternative. Also, they have mattresses for different budgets. When it comes to Lucid, you have all the choice you need.
Sleep on Latex
As the name has stated, Sleep on Latex focuses on Latex mattresses. It was founded in 2013, and has built its well-known brand in the US on natural latex products, including mattresses, toppers, and pillows. It, in collaboration with other latex factories, has developed the gold standard for latex products. Sleep on Latex is the to-go brand for those who love latex mattresses/mattress toppers.
FAQs
Do mattress toppers really work?
It adds an additional supportive layer to your mattress. If you find your old mattress is not supportive enough, instead of having a new mattress, you can consider adding a topper.
What is the difference between a mattress pad and a mattress topper?
They are both products to enhance your comfort while sleeping. A mattress pad is usually a thin pad to add more comfort, while a mattres topper is usually a thicker piece or you can view it as a super-thin mattress that is placed over other mattress.
Is it better to sleep on a hard or soft mattress?
It depends largely on your preference. However, I would recommend a softer mattress for side sleepers, and a firmer mattress for back and stomach sleepers.
Do mattress toppers help back pain?
Yes. A topper adds a supportive layer that helps relieve pressure, so it is beneficial to back pain sufferers.
How long do memory foam mattress toppers last?
A high-quality mattress topper last for 3 - 5 years averagely. If after 5 years, it is still in good, you still should replace it with a new one for hygienic purposes.
Which is better, memory foam or down mattress topper?
Each has its own advantages and disadvantages. You can scroll up to “How to choose the most comfortable mattress topper?” above to see my detailed analysis.
Conclusion
Above is my full review of the most comfortable mattress topper and buying guide. I hope that this article will help you choose the most suitable one.
Eugene WilliamsHi, my name is Eugene, the ultimate home enthusiast! I write buying guides and ideas on how to create a warm and welcoming home. Join me on my journey to make everyday in your house a staycation in the comfort of your own space!
